Two oil based scent places that I was introduced to (thanks Willow!) that I have really enjoyed the scents from are-

http://www.haywardenterprises.com (the only place I've found that can dupe Xeryus Rouge and it smells just like it)

and

http://www.valeriesuncommonscents.com (I had so many compliments on all of her mens colognes but ESPECIALLY Sexy Sandalwood- technically unisex)

The only downside to Valerie's is that the mens scents are mixed in alphabetically with the woman's because she sees them all as being more unisex. It does require a bit of looking but it does make it interesting. Bear in mind that these are artisan scents and thus not for everyone. If you like smelling like every other guy, don't bother going here. If you want to smell great and different from every other guy, they might be worth checking out.

I'd suggest-

Cool Spring
Driftwood
Spiced Mahogony
Sexy Man
Sexy Sandalwood
Werewolf (HOOOOOOOOOOWL!)