I don't know how you got 52 for Xist.
I just counted and it's at 20.

20 people have said they've repurchased Xist (not 52).

Are you counting every instance of the word "Xist" in this thread?
Because it's mentioned in questions and back-and-forth conversations about it.

P.S. One person posted the same comment twice (avi, page 7 + 8):
"Core, Imprint, M3X, Titan, Dionysos, Chamber36
NA
XiSt, Taboo, Evolve
A314, IS, IH, Ammo, P75, P83, P96
AT, GoA, THU
L2K v.1
Androstadienone"

So the above in bold, were counted twice when they should've been counted once (the ones in bold are on the tally list).

I brought the Love God more than once. I've used no other pheromone longer and frequently with consistent results.

Also, 9 commenters mentioned that they repurchased Bad Wolf (not 42).
20 commenters said they repurchased Xist (not 52).

So I'm guessing the tally did one of the following:

1. Included the number of bottles commenters said they purchased
2. Just counted every occurrence of "Xist" in this thread as a hit (I sure hope it's not this one).

This is how I counted the results so a lot of people say they buy lets say xist two, I have counted that as one for xist. Some people have just written the name xist I counted at also as a one for xist. But if someone say three xist I will count that as a two for xist and so on.

here are my results after a recount

A314 (22)

Xist (20)

BW (18)

Sent of eros (13)

New Pheromone Additive.(13)

Core (17)

M3X (10)

Chamber 36 (7)

Cohesion (9)

Evolve (17)

NA (12)

Nos (10)

wolf(7)

Instant Shine (12)

Instant Honesty (9)

Instant Openness (9)

Turn Up The Heat (11)



Androstadienone (7)

AM (9)


Alter Ego (11)

p96 (7)

Ascend (6)

Goa(6)

Anything less than six I've left out. Not that shocking that a314 is top seeing that it was all the rage back when the formula was good, but now no one will touch it.